"Columbus and Columbia: A Brief Survey of the Early Creation of the Columbus Symbol in American History" by: Delno C. West and August Kling in: "Studies in Popular Culture" (XII: 2, 1989, pp. 45-60) When President Ronald Reagan signed the 1988 Columbus Day Proclamation at the White House ceremony in the East Room on October 3, he stressed the importance of the 1992 Quincentenary noting that Christopher Columbus "was the inventor of the Ameri- can dream." The identification with Columbus by Americans has always been an exercise of the imagination. Although a natural symbol for Puritan themes of a new world, new beginnings, para- dise in a new land, he became transformed and secularized into a symbol of unity, national pride, progress and liberty. Christopher Columbus was a devoutly pious man whose mysti- cism was intimately integrated with his thoughts and actions. Throughout his journals and letters, we find him constantly in prayer, invoking the names of Christ, Mary and the saints, and solemnly giving praise to God. He fervently believed that he had been chosen to do a "great work," that he was a man of destiny divinely inspired in thought and action. His religious life was so pronounced that it is commented on by all of his earliest biographers. After locating Paria (South America) on his third voyage, he wrote a lengthy letter to Dona Juana de Torres, recently govern- ess to the infant Prince Juan. Impressed by the fact that he believed that he had come within a few miles of the Terrestrial Paradise, and knowing that he had discovered a continent, he tells the Governess that Apocalypse 21 has been fulfilled: Of the New Heaven and Earth which our Lord has made, and as St. John writes in the Apocalypse, after he had told of it by the mouth of Isaiah, he made me the messenger for it and showed me where to find it. Curiously, the vision of the discoverer, that he had been shown the location of the New Heaven and the New Earth, would become also the vision of the new hemisphere as it sought to achieve its own identity and meaning. The formation of the symbolic meaning of Christopher Colum- bus to America in the late eighteenth century and the perpetua- tion of that meaning into the nineteenth century has been ignored by American historians. This was a time in which Columbus became Columbia and a myth was formed about the Admiral, a time in which a Genoese explorer in the service of Spain, a mariner who never touched the shores of North America, became the symbol of Ameri- can pride and progress. The Columbus symbol has played a role in the political and poetic myths about America's beginnings, history and future. Our latest nuclear submarine was commissioned in the summer of 1988 and named "Columbia." And, we continue the legacy with space ships and space shuttles named "Columbia" and "Discovery." Examples for this essay will be limited to literature, art and public celebrations, but as a figure who has captured the Ameri- can imagination on a level equal to that of George Washington and Abraham Lincoln, the symbolic meaning of Columbus appears every- where. A monograph would be necessary in order to analyze the iconography of Columbus in numismatics, philately, children's literature and school books, American popular history and text- books, ethnic movements, and as patron of science and technology. For example, Columbus was described in heroic terms and a man of great character in McGuffery and other early readers. Early in this century, the Columbian Liberty and Peace Bell accompanied by the "Liberty Primer" was distributed widely to American elementa- ry schools. Copied from the great "Columbian Liberty Bell" in front of Union Station in Washington D.C., the primer and bell were designated to promote Americanism among American youth. The iconography of the Columbian symbol became complicated early on in our history when Columbus became "Columbia" a female figure more akin to "liberty" and "American unity" in the public mind. A lengthy analysis of the history of female representation in the portrayal of the body politic of a nation is unnecessary here. Several recent studies by Marina Warner and others have followed the metamorphoses of the Greek goddess of liberty into Columbia. These studies have shown the close connection of such transformation to the French Revolution and European iconography seeking a chaste mother to represent the ideals of a Republic. As Warner pointed out in her book, "Monuments and Maidens", the Statue of Liberty, for example, which is a version of the allego- ry of Columbia, "anticipates continuously a future that is always in the process of becoming." A change toward secularization and feminization began following the War of Independence when "Columbia" was used as a unifying force for the thirteenth separate states, and later to reunify the union after the Civil War. Yet, the older spiritual meaning attached to Columbus was reborn and reused at the turn of the twentieth century by American Catholics in their struggle for equality. There are many Biblical archetypes in U.S. history--the exodus, chosen people, promised land, New Jerusalem, sacrificial death and rebirth. We have developed our own prophets and martyrs, sacred events and sacred places, our own rituals and symbols. Christopher Columbus is one of the more interesting of these and least understood for his life and name came to have both spiritual and secular meaning. A definition might be in order at this point: Columbus, is a Latin masculine noun meaning a male dove. Columba is the feminine form of the noun. Yet, by the time of the revolution, a new form of the word had appeared: "Columbia" which was listed in the "Century Dictionary and Cyclopedia" as "a new Latin form derived from Columbus. Columbia is the poetical name of the United States of America." Christopher Columbus already had been adopted as a symbol of liberation and progress by North Americans during the era of the Colonial period. The spiritual meaning of the New World to the people of colonial New England incorporated important elements of self-awareness and world-consciousness. Very early they devel- oped values, identity, purpose, expectations and especially hope from Christian eschatology. One of the earliest examples of this is a fascinating book published in 1697, by a chief justice in Boston, Samuel Sewall. He wrote a book which he titled, "Phaenomena quaedum Apocalyptica ad aspectum Novi Orbis configurata", or "some few lines Towards a Description of the New Heaven as it Makes (seems) to Those Who Stand Upon the New Earth." The "New Earth" he speaks of is, of course, the New World, and especially the still small and struggling colonies of New England. The "New Heaven" is a rather unusual way of refer- ring to the spiritual meaning of the New World, which Sewall insisted should be called "Columbina" rather than "America." Samuel Sewall wrote his book in defense of the colonies which were receiving "bad press" by Protestant theologians at Oxford and Cambridge. These most learned Bible scholars had concluded that the New World was the Biblical "infernal region," or in plain English, "hell." Sewall insisted that descriptions of the New World should be given by people who had lived there and who knew what they were talking about. Furthermore, there were other prophecies in the book of Revelations better suited to identification with the New World. There were those glorious prophecies of the New Jerusa- lem. And Sewall went on to show how North America could properly be marked the New Jerusalem or "New Heaven" or Promised Land on the spiritual map. The most impressive lines in Sewall's book are in huge bold type: LIFT UP YOUR HEADS, O YE GATES (OF COLUMBINA) AND BE YE LIFT UP, YE EVERLASTING DOORS, AND THE KING OF GLORY SHALL COME IN. The name "Columbina" had a special prophetic meaning to Sewall. He explained that it referred to the hero for whom the New World should rightly be named, "rather call it Columbina, from the magnanimous hero Christopher Columbus, a Genuese, who was manifestly appointed of God to be the Finder out of these lands." Sewall goes on to describe the English colonies as the "marriageable younger sister," the New Jerusalem, waiting for the arrival of the heavenly bridegroom. Although Sewall wished to name the country "Columbina," others chose the version of "Columbia." The Boston poet, Phyllis Wheatley (1753-1784), who as a small child had been kidnapped from her African homeland by slave traders, was the first to use in print (in her poem, "To His Excellency General Washington") the name "Columbia" as a poetic designation for the aspirations of the new republic in 1775. Jonathan Edwards, minister and President of the College of New Jersey (later Princeton) began to link the powerful theme of the discovery of the New World and the prophecies of the earthly millennium at the end of human history. Edwards concluded from his studies of prophecies and of history that the discovery of the New World was a preparatory state for the dawning of the earthly millennium in the Western World. He wrote in 1773 ("Thoughts on the Revival in New England") that the New World would lead the old world in progress toward that expectation: This new world is probably now discovered, that the new and most glorious state of God's church on earth might commense there; that God might in it begin a new world in spiritual respect, when he creates the new heavens and new earth. When he accepted the presidency of the College of New Jersey in 1757, Edwards explained that he was completing his major work, a new method of theology written in the form of universal histo- ry. Edwards had worked through the prophecies of the Bible and related them to the ages and events of human history, forming what he called the "History of the Work of Redemption". The climax of this history was to be a new age of spiritual and material fulfillment prophesied as the millennium. Christopher Columbus also emerged as a popular hero during the American Revolutionary War. The tattered troops of General Washington's army were frequently called the "Columbian host." As they marched they sometimes sang a popular patriotic song, "Columbia, Columbia, to Glory Arise," written by a chaplain of the Connecticut Continental Brigade who was already jotting down verses for the first epic of the New Republic. Timothy Dwight, the chaplain, while a young instructor at Yale College, had joined a group of dissident students known as the "sons of freedom." Appropriately, the group of literary and revolutionary students styled themselves the "Columbians." Later, when Presi- dent of Yale College, he wrote his poem, "Conquest of Canaan". In his poem, he first told the story of Moses and the Exodus, then presented the vision of the New Age and the New World as seen from atop Mt. Pisgah. Dwight identified Christopher Colum- bus as "a new Moses" who "through trackless seas, an unknown flight explores, and hails a new canaan's promised shores." In his footnotes, Dwight interpreted his verses as they unfolded a prophetic preview of history continuing from ancient times to the end of the world. Far into his poem, he reached what he called the "Vision of America," with the promise of great social, economic and scientific progress for the new nation. This prospect of future progress for the new nation is open-ended and limitless. These same boundless expectations for the future of America were elaborated in other poems by Timothy Dwight. Shortly after the birth of the New Nation, the first commem- orative celebrations of Columbus' discovery were held in New York City, Baltimore and Boston. In New York City, the activities were organized by the "Tammany Society or Columbian Order" (the name is derived from an early American Indian Christian martyr and Christopher Columbus). In 1792, the Tammany Society or Columbian Order was a highly respected club whose membership included everyone of importance in New York City. The commemora- tive was billed as the celebration of "the greatest event in the history of mankind since the death of our Saviour." A statue of Columbus was raised at Tammany Hall (or the "Wigwam" as they called it then), and an eloquent oration was delivered by Mr. John B. Johnson followed by dinner and evening entertainment. After dinner the toasts were many. Among the more interesting were the following: Toast no. 7: May the genius of liberty, as she has conducted the sons of Columbia with glory to the com- mencement of the fourth century, guard their fame to the end of time. Toast no. 8: The memory of the renowned Columbus--may our latest posterity inherit the goodly land which his intrepidity explored, and his sagacity discovered. In Baltimore and Boston similar ceremonies were held. In Baltimore, a memorial column was erected with proper ceremony. While in Boston a dinner celebration was held by the recently formed Massachusetts Historical Society featuring an oration by the Rev. Jeremy Belknap. After the oration, the memory of Columbus was "toasted in convivial enjoyment, and the warmest wishes were expressed that the blessings now distinguishing the United States might be extended to every part of the world he has discovered." In this same year, the plan for the District of Columbia was printed and displayed for the public sale of building lots. Records of the day are silent as to the reason why the federal territory was named to honor Christopher Columbus, or whether other names were considered. Most likely the name was chosen to appease those who were lobbying to change the name of America to Columbia. All we know is that the name was decided upon by the three commissioners selected by President Washington. The lack of information is not surprising, as we know General Washington and the aides he chose were people of action, short on verbal ceremonies and public explanations. But there is in the Capitol further visible evidence of the choice of the Genoese mariner as a national symbol. At the top of the wide stone steps of the nation's capitol were placed the marble statues (now moved to the Smithsonian) of an awed native maiden viewing a Christopher Columbus in armor holding a globe on which is carved the word "America." As one stands before the huge bronze Columbus doors, designed and cast by Randolph Rogers, opening into the rotunda, many symbolic figures remind the viewer of the relationship between Columbus and America. The most obvious are the nine spectacular panels depicting scenes from the Admiral's life. At the top of the doors is a bust of Columbus surrounded by laurel wreaths above draped American flags resting on an eagle. Rogers drew the design for the doors while studying in Florence, Italy, copying the doors from the famous Ghiberti "Gates of Paradise" to the Cathedral baptistery. Entering the rotunda, there is the magnificent first fresco by John Venderlyn picturing a highly stylized landing of Columbus on San Salvador island in 1492. This is only the first of many paintings, busts, statues and frescos of Columbus in the capitol building done throughout the nineteenth century by famous Ameri- can artists. Nor is the Capitol building the only site for works of art with a Columbian theme. There is art all over Washington D.C. dedicated to the Admiral; for example, the magnificent memorial in front of Union Station or the marble bust of Columbus in the main vestibule of the White House. The naming of the federal territory in honor of Christopher Columbus and filling the city with works of art depicting his life was not just a romantic reference to a picturesque moment in the history of the New World. In it was a powerful symbolism expressing the deepest ideals and values of our national heritage and hopes for the future. Such a rhapsody of symbolism expressed newly accepted notions of national identity, ideals and goals. The choice was no coincidence. Paintings, statues and monuments multiplied in the nine- teenth century with significant representations in New York, Chicago, Boston, Baltimore, Buffalo, San Francisco, Richmond and elsewhere. Besides columns and monuments, artists narrated Columbus' most dramatic adventures. He was the symbol of indi- vidualism and our primary example of progress. Art historians have only begun to study the iconography of this heroic statuary and paintings. The Columbian theme continued after 1792 as the symbol of the new nation and the ideals for which it stood. Philip Freneau, the brilliant popularizer of America and its future and the so-called "poet of the American Revolution," in 1779 wrote his "Pictures of Columbus" which idealized a golden age in the land of opportunity found first by Christopher Columbus. Joel Barlow, a student of Timothy Dwight and also a member of the "sons of Freedom," or "Columbians" at Yale, secularized and expanded Dwight's themes in his epic poems, "The Vision of Columbus" (1787) and "The Columbiad" (1807). In his "Vision of Columbus" he introduced Christopher Columbus as a "great seer," the "first sage," the New World "chief," the "hero" of the New Age, whose prophetic vision brought to birth a New Age of "happi- ness to the human race." In his poem, "The Columbiad", Christo- pher Columbus is taken to the highest mountain in Spain by the Greek god Hesper where Hesper causes the future of the New World discovered by Columbus to unfold. Progress in human life, the arts, and science are all seen accomplished by hordes of immi- grants who would travel to the new land. In Book IX, of the poem, Columbus is shown the Federal system of government in America and told that this system will spread over the entire world. The name of Columbus became associated with the expanding destiny of the new nation. Five patriotic songs of "the United States of Columbia" were used in the Independence era and pub- lished in 1798 in the "American Musical Miscellany". When the northwest coast of the continent was explored in 1792 by Captain Robert Gray, he named the gushing river he encountered "Colum- bia," after his ship, "Columbia Rediviva," and his country thereby linking the river to the destiny of America. The river had been overlooked by the British explorer Vancouver which caused continued embarrassment to the British who were forced to adopt the poetic name of America when discussing territorial rights in the Northwest. The Columbian symbolism is eschatological and deeply spiri- tual. It speaks of liberty from old world tyranny, hope for the future, and a vision of new beginnings in a new world in a new age. The vision is more than spiritual; it involves the specif- ics of human rights, economic growth, development in technology, progress in social and physical sciences. Perhaps best of all there is no separation of the material from the spiritual: The Columbus symbolism includes both. The two great heros and symbols of early American history, Columbus and Washington, became chiseled into the American mind in the early nineteenth century with the multi-volume biographies written by Washington Irving. Earlier writers we have covered had access to English histories of the discoveries, particularly those by George Peckham and Richard Hakluyt, and some had even quoted from Ferdinand's biography of his father and Peter Martyr's "De orbe Novo", but Irving was the first American writer to have access to the newly collected Columbus documents gathered by the great Spanish scholar Martin Fernandez de Navarrete. Although written from the sources and the best biographies to that time, the Columbus and Washington volumes present a sort of Romulus and Remus for the founding of America. Columbus was the finder of the New World, inspired by God, leading the way for men to establish a classic "golden age." Washington was the libera- tor of that world who freed it to follow its destiny. Walt Whitman and other writers continued the theme to turn Columbus into a romantic hero. The great twentieth-century historian of Columbus, Samuel Elliot Morison revised the hero and turned him into the practical, tough-minded navigator whose achievements were more a result of intestinal fortitude and knowledge of the Ocean Sea than divine guidance. However, the dream was almost shattered by the war between the states. Once again Columbus stepped forward from the past to symbolize the hopes of the new nation. In the Vice President's office of the Capitol building, the huge ceiling mural was painted after the war showing "Columbia," draped in the stars and stripes, receiving the south back into the union. Poets, too, seized the opportunity to connect Columbus once again with the nation's history. Hinahan Cornwallis, in his popular account, "The War for the Union, or the Duel Between the North and South: U.S.A. 1861-1865, A Poetical Panorama, Historical and Descrip- tive" prefaced his history with a 275 page epic poem titled "The Song of America and Columbus, or the Story of the New World." The lines of the poem attempt to merge Columbus with Columbia: What wealth and splendor far and wide we view! What wondrous progress since Columbus came, And woke this New World to eternal fame! Or, Queen of the Great Republic of the West, With shining stars and stripes upon thy breast-- The emblems of our land of liberty:-- Thou namesake of Columbus--hail to thee! . . . Columbia! to Columbus give thy hand! One other important representations of Columbus should be mentioned which surfaced in the late nineteenth century: the ethnic Columbus. Strangely enough, this image was conceived by Irish Catholic fraternalists and popularized by Italo-American communities in the twentieth century with the creation of nation- al "Columbus Day" holiday. The Knights of Columbus was formed in New Haven, Conn. in 1882 as a fraternity for Catholic men, as a patriotic society to promote ideas of Americanism, as an insurance society, as a response to adverse New England Protestant attitudes toward Irish Catholic immigrants, and as a youth program for young Catholic men. Fr. McGivney, local parish priest and instigator of the first council of the knights, had from the beginning the idea of naming the order after Christopher Columbus. Early meeting records show that he originally wished to call the organization the "Sons of Columbus." The name was chosen because Columbus' first act was to plant the cross of Christ on the New World shores, "a symbol of his sacred commission." Highly successful, the Knights rapidly became the world's largest Catholic confra- ternity. The history of the Knights of Columbus has been written in a superb book by Christopher Kauffman, "Faith and Fraternalism, The History of the Knights of Columbus"; and in the past few years the Knights have created a well organized archive and museum at their world headquarters in New Haven. By the 1890s, Columbianism began to be confused with the Catholic Americanism movement led by Archbishop John Ireland. Catholic Americanism was a deeply spiritual and patriotic belief in the transformation of America into a New World Christian Republic of a new people in a new age resulting from an encounter between Catholicism and American culture. Within the organization, itself, the fourth degree of knighthood was established to promote American citizenship. Thomas Cummings explained the role of citizenship within the Knights of Columbus in an article which appeared in "Donahoe's Magazine" in 1895. Inspired by Christopher Columbus, "a prophet and a seer, an instrument of Divine Providence, a mystic of the highest order each knight becomes a better Catholic and a better citizen." Within a few years, Columbianism became the promise of a new age, a new Catholic manhood representing the best the New World had to offer. The ceremonial for the fourth degree cen- tered on Catholic citizenship: To Catholics, America can give thanks for her discov- ery, her exploration, her very name . . . Christopher Columbus, prophetic name. Christopher, Christbearer-- Columbus, a dove, the sacred emblem of the Holy Spirit. A dove was to be a Christ-bearer to a new world and new peoples . . . How wholly Catholic is the discovery, Catholic in its inception, Catholic in its impulses; Catholic in its actors; . . . Catholic in its baptism; Catholic in its progress. The Columbus memorial in front of Union Station in Washing- ton D.C. was the ultimate expression of Columbianism and Ameri- canism. Although commissioned and paid for by the U.S. Congress, the memorial was a Knights of Columbus project from the begin- ning. They lobbied for it, the Supreme Knight was the only non- congressional member of the commission, and 500 knights paraded at the unveiling of the memorial on June 8, 1912. The Rector of The Catholic University of America led the invocation and Victor Dowling, a former National Director of the Knights of Columbus and a justice of the Supreme Court gave the oration. The speech was Columbian and American: Here was no Alexander, sighing for new worlds to con- quer, but here was the apostolic spirit for one who signed for quicker ways to make known to distant lands the sweetness of Faith and the light of Hope. Here was one who . . . believed in his star; but the star of Columbus was the star of Bethlehem. These Catholic patriotic forces which swirled around the symbol of Christopher Columbus were not limited to memorials, parades and rituals within the fraternity. They also led to important academic contributions to American history with the establishment of a Chair in American History at The Catholic University of America in 1899 and the Historical Commission of the Knights in 1921. The Historical Commission, concerned with the intensely Protestant slant to American history and the growth of lunatic fringe groups such as the Ku Klux Klan, encouraged new studies of American history which would incorporate contributions by all settlers of the United States. Powerful social and political forces are released in the compounded symbols of discovery and the earthly millennium. This is not to claim that the symbols generate the forces, but that the adoption of such symbols reveals and encourages the forces of change, development and even revolution. The operation of these forces in the life of the New Nation was embodied in the Chicago World's Columbian Exposition of 1893. It was time for self- congratulatory backslapping. A time to stand back and admire over a century of accomplishments. No symbol could have better represented the spirit of American advancements or stood for the unlimited future possibility of the new nation than that of Christopher Columbus. The nation that had chosen to inscribe on its great seal the phrases "New Order of the Ages" and "God has favored our undertaking" celebrated its pride and progress with the most gala and enthusiastic event in the history of the Western Hemisphere. Although the Chicago World's Columbian Exposition did not open until May 1, 1893, the Columbus Day festivities in October, 1892 were a prelude in anticipation of the great event. a grand civic parade of more than 80,000 participants led by the Presi- dent of the United States and including the entire Cabinet, the Supreme Court, and most of congress launched the year-long cele- bration. It was billed in the "Memorial Volume. Dedicatory and Opening Ceremonies of the World's Columbian Exposition" (1893) as the "festival of the nations . . . The Columbian epic . . . traces the strange adventures of the Genoese seer . . . to the very moment that beholds us here, citizens, freemen, equal share- holders, in the miracle of American civilization and development . . . the jubilee of mankind." That evening at the inaugural ceremonies, Archbishop Ireland delivered the oration and summa- rized the meaning of Columbus to patriotic Americans: Behold the crowning gift to humanity from Columbus, whose caravels ploughed ocean's uncertain billows in search of a great land, and from the all-ruling Provi- dence whose wisdom and mercy inspired and guided the immortal Genoese mariner--the United States of America. Later in May, the President returned to throw the switch on the newfangled source of energy, electricity, which set in motion all the mechanical devices of the exposition. Following the President, Dr. Milburn, the blind chaplain of the Senate of the United States, rose to pray. He gave thanks for the "feast of tabernacles in this place" commemorating "that most momentous of all voyages by which Columbus lifted the veil that hid the New World from the old and opened the gateway of the future of mankind." Next, Miss Jessie Couthoui, dressed in a Castillian costume stepped to the lectern and with clear voice and faultless diction she read a poem written by W. A. Croffut entitled "The Prophecy," describing the tense days of October, 1492 as the men on the three small ships were near the point of mutiny. "Columbus sought a sign" the poet says, and "Like elfin shadows on an open sea, prophetic pictures of the land he sought . . . an empire, radiant as the day, harnessed to law, but under Freedom's sway, Proudly arise, resplendent in array, To show the world the way." The poem then describes aspects of the new nation's progress, which are here described as having been fulfilled, and the long poem concludes with: Lo! thro' this segment of the watery world Uprose a hemisphere of glorious life, A realm of golden grain and fragrant fruits, And men and women wise and masterful, Who dwelt at peace in rural cottages And splendid cities bursting into bloom-- Great Lotus blossoms on a flowery sea; And happiness was there, and bright-winged hope-- High aspiration, soaring to the stars . . . The historical volume written for the exposition was titled, "Columbus and Columbia: A Pictorial History of the Man and the Nation" (1893). The book speaks of Columbus' crew as the "Colum- bian argonauts," and describes the Admiral in these words: The story of Columbus is . . . a narration of bold conception, persistent courage, heroic attainment . . . The adventures of the Homeric Ulysses were not more illustrious with valor . . . no character in the world's history was ever more highly honored for chiv- alrous achievement . . . He was a product of the brave days of old. Let us end, then, with how Columbus himself viewed the meaning of his discovery and its effect upon the world and the future. In announcing his discovery to the world by a letter dated February 15, 1493, the Admiral wrote: The eternal God, our Lord, gives to those who walk in his ways the victory in things that seem impossible. And this was one such notable case. Because people had spoken or written about these lands before, but it was all guesswork, without getting a look at it. It all amounted only to hearsay that people judged to be fables, or thought little of it. And then our Redeemer gave this triumph . . . For this all of Christendom should rejoice, and make great celebrations, and make solemn thanksgivings to the Holy Trinity, with much solemn prayer. May Christ rejoice on the earth as he does in heaven as he sees that so many peoples hitherto lost are now to be saved. Let us also rejoice for the extension of our faith, and also for the increase of material goods . . . in the future. Permission granted by author WESTKLN1.ART"