Buttonwood Tree House

In 1937, telephone linemen who were sent to install phone lines in the "Chicken Pie Place" Restaurant in Hellam, York County found an arched German fruit cellar hewn from solid rock. The Buttonwood Tree House, which takes its name from the large buttonwood tree in the front yard, is built like a fortress, on solid rock, with walls 24 inches thick. The original house was built in approximately 1760. It was remodeled sometime between 1810 and 1820. The house is located 8 miles east of York City. It sits midway between York City and Columbia.

A prominent businessman in both York and Lancaster Counties, Abraham Hiestand bought the building in 1830. Hiestand also owned the Old York Inn, which was another known Underground Railroad stop in York County. Sarah Wilson, Hiestand's daughter inherited the property and owned it from 1865 to 1899. She continued to help fugitives in the latter days of the Civil War.

It was in the hidden cellar that fugitive slaves were hidden. The means of entry into the cellar was via a fireplace in the living room. In the living room fireplace, a hole large enough for a large person to slide down into the otherwise completely walled in cellar was concealed. When strangers were present a log fire was kept burning in the fireplace and the hole was covered with stones.

The side of the Buttonwood Tree House on Route 462 in Hellam. The entrance to the hidden cellar is under the

far left window of the porch.

 

The entrance to the hidden cellar.

Interior of the cellar, showing hooks for hanging cured meats and vent holes allegedly

used by runaway slaves as exits or entrances to the cellar.

A close-up of a vent hole which, like the others, has been mortared shut.

A turn of the century photograph of the front of the Buttonwood Tree House. The house was locally known as

the "Chicken Pie" House for its owners' business of selling food to travellers on the Lincoln Highway. This and

other photographs of the house show how the hidden cellar was used as an attraction: The sign at far right

(in this photo unreadable) said "See the Slave Cellar."

William Goodridge House

Elmwood Mansion

Griest/Kirk House

Willis House

Buttonwood Tree House

Old York Valley Inn

Wrightsville/Columbia Bridge

Mifflin House

HOME